Weekly insights about property in France!

Subscribe and don't miss an issue!

A Rant on the Short-Term Rental Laws in France

Volume XX, Issue 30

A veiw of apartment buildings in Paris

Apologies in advance for this rant! I’m really getting tired and fed up with the laws that govern property rentals. This is because we are faced daily with it as a problem, whether it’s from the side of the tenant or the landlord. Both are suffering and I’m having a hard time understanding why anyone needs to suffer at all.

Call me an anarchist, but the “straightjacket” that the cities are putting landlords in to rent or not to rent don’t appear to benefit anyone but the hotels and big corporations, as they certainly do not benefit the individual homeowner or person who simply needs a place to live…for a week, a month, a year or a lifetime. For some reason, they have been largely forgotten.

Google map showing rental properties available in Paris

Map showing rental properties available in Paris

When you purchase a property for your own use or investment, in a multi-family building, then it’s a given that as one of the owners, you must abide by the rules of the homeowner association. Everyone has an equal voice in how it is to be managed. We expect to live by those rules and if the owners in the building wish to restrict “transient” residency, then by all means, they should be able to do so. But, how can the city or the country have the right to override the owners’ decisions by adding further restrictions? They do assume they have the right and they do take it, often very seriously and very restrictively, without thinking of the consequences.

Example of an apartment in France that could be available for short-term rental

The city administrators’ goal is to put more long-term housing on the market, considering the shortage certain cities are facing. I understand the need and the problem, but what I object to is the solution they have devised, by attacking the short-term rental market. While short-term properties may contribute to the shortage, it is by no means the only reason the shortage exists. In fact, much of it stems from the way landlords are treated as “the money-grubbing bad guys,” which is an incentive for not renting their property at all and just leaving it vacant while it appreciates in value with no investment to improve it. So, many properties sit vacant, rotting away, contributing to the shortage. I believe the authorities need to dig a little deeper into the real reasons they are faced with the shortages rather than use the short-term market as their “scapegoat.” I honestly believe they haven’t done their “homework.”

What I have witnessed from the fallout has not only hurt the landlords, but has also hurt the tenants. The ones that are benefiting are the large establishments, like the hotels and the corporations which can afford to buy up entire buildings and convert them into what is known as “aparthotels.” This leaves the average homeowner “holding his own bag” with no revenue to show from his investment. You would think that a socialist democracy of this kind wouldn’t be so quick to let the little guys suffer while the big guys are “laughing all the way to the bank.” It surprises me they are so shortsighted.

We are faced daily with clients seeking a rental property and having a struggle finding properties willing to accept them as tenants, because of the laws that punish the landlords, and end up acting against them in this way. Then, there are owners seeking ways of filling their properties to cover their costs of ownership, being left empty-handed with nothing to show for their efforts.

Example of an apartment in France that could be available for short-term rental

The lawmakers have somehow forgotten that people have a broad range of needs. One of which that has grown exponentially since Covid-19 is the need for shorter-term accommodation—less than one year. Now that we can work remotely, we no longer need to be in any one place for long periods of time, so shorter-term rentals can be ideal…but they are dwindling here in France as the laws prevent home owners from doing what they should be able to do: let anyone they want stay in their own property!

Keep this is mind when battling the local regulations! Don’t let anyone tell you that you can’t let anyone you want stay in your own property! And the only difference is whether they have paid to cover your expenses or not…call it “rent” or call it a “reimbursement of expenses,” but there is a cost to home ownership and someone must pay for it, you or the other person staying in your home, friend, relative or tenant.

Example of an apartment in France that could be available for short-term rental

In France, renting is considered a commercial activity within the meaning of town planning. It is differentiated from those properties intended for housing. This is confusing because how can it be one or the other? It’s not “black or white.” Surely, renting falls into both categories? But, from a legal standpoint, the authorities have decided that it’s more about the money than the housing. I can’t wrap my head around this.

In cities of a population of 200,000 or more, it is compulsory in France to change the usage of the premises from residential to commercial to legally accept short-term rentals, but not long-term rentals. So, what is considered short-term? Even this is a good question, as it could be ambiguous. Most consider short-term for vacation use only, but in today’s world of transiency and the ability to work remotely, does that definition stand? And how long is short-term? One night? One week? One month?

Example of an apartment in France that could be available for short-term rental

A change of usage is no easy task, either. To legally change a property from residential to commercial requires the permission of the building as well as the city. Good luck getting that to happen! We must be dreaming.

France is not alone in this and must abide by the laws of the European Union. Certain French local regulations must be reworked to be in conformity with European law. Article 9 of the Services Directive aims to ensure an adequate supply of housing for long-term rental at affordable prices. This criteria must meet the justification of the city regulations, made obligatory by the European law.

Paris isn’t the only city faced with the problem. Eleven French towns fall into the category of more than 200,000 inhabitants governing these laws: Paris, Marseille, Lyon, Toulouse, Nice, Nantes, Montpellier, Strasbourg, Bordeaux, Lille and Rennes.

As you may recall, I was just in Lille taping a House Hunters International episode, about finding a property to rent for a young Kansas couple. Lille (and the entire area including Lomme and Hellemmes) has adopted a rule to limit short-term rental accommodations, by virtue of an authorization scheme granted on the condition that the property that was converted into furnished tourist accommodation is compensated for by the creation of a dwelling in a place in the city which has another purpose. (Download a PDF version of the actual directive)

Meme for changing the usage purpose of your French apartment

Try that one on for size! This means you’re investing in two properties; not just one. In Nice, permission to change the usage to accommodate tourists is subject to compensation through the creation of another property in a place intended for economic activity. This is true in Paris, too, and they justify it by the so-called shortage of long-term rental housing in the cities. Strasbourg and Lyon are subject to the same rules.

In Nice, you may rent short-term for up to six years if you have permission of the building and the city. If your application is rejected, you can appeal the decision. While the decision is under appeal, which could take a very long time, you can legally rent! Put that in your pipe and smoke it!

Meme for Airbnb rules in Nice, France

Why am I on this “soapbox?” Because I believe that the city administrators are short-sighted and misguided. I don’t believe they’ve done any real studies to understand what causes their housing shortages, yet have chosen to attack Airbnb and the vacation rental market as an easy out. The public is mostly on their side because there are fewer investors than there are permanent residents who favor the restrictions. These are the folks who complain about the “transients” who come in and out of their buildings with suitcases, making noise and who they believe they can’t trust. But, transiency is growing as we no longer need to go to work in an office miles from home.

Just take me, for example. I go in and out of my building almost weekly with suitcases, yet I’m a “permanent” resident…who travels a lot. And I’m no different than most people I know! In today’s world, I believe that ultimately the transients may outweigh the permanents.

You understand, I’m just blowing off steam here because this rant will go on deaf ears, but it’s affected our clients and business adversely from the beginning and I know no one it benefits. While the little guys, who are just trying to cover their expenses by offering their property to visitors during a time it would normally be vacant, are prevented from earning a few extra bucks and make some newcomer to France happy, the hotels are raking it in, as are the developers who can afford to buy up whole buildings and convert them into cookie-cutter apartments that lack personality or charm.

Example of an apartment in France that could be available for short-term rental

The cities are happy with hotels and aparthotels because they can rake in tax money, but if they were smart about it, they could be financially benefiting from the short-term apartments, too. It’s pretty pathetic if you ask me, and I have better ways of solving the problem.

What if everyone was allowed to have only one property they call a short-term rental, not 10? And what if that property had to be registered and comply with certain standards? And what if there was a system to rate the accommodations, like the hotel star system? And why not allow the building owners to have their own say in what they do with their own property, not the city? I’ll bet they would be even more restrictive than the city if they governed themselves…especially those in less touristed neighborhoods.

So, in the end, the city would have a well managed, well organized block of tourist (call them “transient”) accommodations that are designed as glorified hotel rooms (and not just a bed in someone else’s primary residence) that enhances tourism, makes their visitors feel like they’re “at home” and ultimately satisfying all parties, including reducing the housing shortage by not forcing these same properties to remain vacant and useless? It would encourage property investment and the upkeep of the buildings to maintain their properties’ values and prevent the city from becoming a slum! There are many other ways to “skin this cat” that they haven’t thought of, or wanted to consider. And I don’t get it.

A touristed street in Lille, France

One last note: this isn’t just about tourist accommodation. What about those who need a few months of accommodations? Let’s say you’re renovating your apartment and need a place to live? What if you’re separating from your spouse and need to a place to live…for just a while? What if you want to live in many different places during the year just because you can?

The laws don’t consider these people, but they should. President Emmanuel Macron created the Mobility Lease which is great for people traveling on business or education, but what about the rest of us who are retired and just want a 90 day visit? We can be in France for 90 days without a visa, but we’re not entitled to housing! And why prevent the landlord of this type of accommodation from taking a security deposit? (The law doesn’t allow it; can you imagine that!?) So, why is the landlord being punished in this way?

Yep, I’m full of questions. That’s because I can’t make sense of what the authorities are trying to accomplish. I watch a tangled web of undecipherable laws baffle us all and that are ultimately counter productive to what they are trying to achieve.

It’s just plain stupid.

A bientôt,

Adrian Leeds with mouth open, rantingAdrian Leeds
The Adrian Leeds Group®

Adrian in full rant mode

P.S. Last night we co-hosted the North American Expat Financial Forum Quarterly Seminar devoted to the topic of “Currency Opportunities & Social Security for US Expats Abroad.” It was a fun and informative session. If you missed it last night, you don’t have to miss it now! Tune in to YouTube to see and hear the entire one-hour with Brian Dunhill, Kam Somal, Josh Madden, Anya Berezow, Patty Sadauskas and myself for an education on these important issues!

P.P.S. When we search for properties on your behalf, we review all of the building bylaws to determine your rights as a landlord and to ensure that if you wish to rent a furnished apartment, you can. We also have staff who can assist you in submitting your applications for short-term rental. So, don’t be afraid of the laws! Just let us help you manage them or find ways around them to suit your needs! There are always solutions, even if the city administrators didn’t think of them!

SHARE THIS POST

18 Comments

  1. Colin and Janice Clarke on August 4, 2022 at 10:56 am

    Good rant. Justified. I can imagine how a dozen or more new Air BNB visitors every month, stumbling around in your residential building at all hours and (some) being inconsiderate would be very annoying. But for the rest, the one to three or four tourists (or visitors from other Fr cities) every month, is surely acceptable, and good for owners, and the cities. On our visits to Paris, we have always taken an apartment – average 10 days – simply because a hotel room is claustrophobic over that time. Not to mention, hit and miss hotel service, and “breakfast”. Fight the good fight, Adrian. Rant. And find nice places with 199,999 residents. 🙏🏻

  2. Nan Johnson on August 4, 2022 at 11:00 am

    Oh Adrian! How things have changed since we had our first conversation with you about moving over to Paris from the U.S. About six years ago. This makes no sense to be sure. Now we’re wondering if we’ll ever be able to come over for only a year! Thanks for all you’re doing to keep us informed.

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 4, 2022 at 11:09 am

      Of course you can come for a year. One-year rentals are legal!

  3. Merrill Bloor on August 4, 2022 at 11:08 am

    Living in an area with a high amount of rental properties, I can see both sides, but your rant is well spoken and you are right, no one will listen.

    Merrill
    (I am a huge fan of yours, you tell it like it is, always and your patience with the clients is nothing short of miraculous!)

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 4, 2022 at 11:14 am

      Thank you so much!

  4. Brian Carlisto on August 4, 2022 at 11:14 am

    Hi Adrian,

    I can understand your frustration. You make some very good points.
    How do these new laws effect fractional ownership apartments?
    Is it possible to own a fractional ownership property in Nice with one person owns 10 month and one or two other own the months of July and August?

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 5, 2022 at 6:25 am

      The laws have zero effect on fractional ownership. As a developer you can structure fractional usage however you want.

  5. Alison on August 4, 2022 at 11:14 am

    You go girl!! Tell it!!

  6. Ann Rushing on August 4, 2022 at 11:22 am

    We rented one of the apartments shown in your rant. We would rent again if we knew how to find it.

    Keep ranting!

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 5, 2022 at 6:21 am

      As mentioned, we are no longer in the short-term rental business. Thank you for your past business.

  7. Christy Rudner on August 4, 2022 at 3:18 pm

    Thank you so much for your rant, I agree and have investment property sitting empty because of exactly what you have ranted about. I am going to work on a different direction with my properties. I have also wanted to buy a property in France and I am going to get in touch with you so I can learn what I will be up against if I go in this direction.

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 5, 2022 at 6:19 am

      We would love to assist you with your property search in France. Let us know how we can help.

  8. Carolyn Wade on August 4, 2022 at 3:57 pm

    The way to change this is small town by small town, by persuading the local residents that the overreaching by their local administrators harms them–so they should protest the new regulations and vote out the administrators that put them in place. It starts small, but it has to start with grassroots, permanent, FRENCH voters to begin a movement.

    Everything you’ve said is correct–and the homeowners need to learn how they are affected by regulations that they may not be feeling the immediate pinch of, but which will have long-term effects that should be nipped in the bud. One town changes, becomes news, another one says “Hey, that’s true for us, too!” and maybe some bigger change can happen. But you need a political organizer to get started.

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 5, 2022 at 6:19 am

      Thank you for sharing your comments.

  9. Trish Young on August 4, 2022 at 7:37 pm

    Don’t apologise! Your Spanish mayor of Paris has made my heart cry.
    I enjoyed my 4 to 6 weeks annual vacation in Paris. Made more enjoyable by the Adrian Leeds apartment group. The apartments were beautifully maintained with all the mod cons of home. And, very importantly, fluffy towels.
    And I never felt isolated as help was only a phone call away.
    A friend once rented an apartment (from a different agency) and whilst it was a good size, she had one towel, no change of sheets and the toilet broke down and they wouldn’t fix it.
    I did want to buy an apartment I Paris, but this was stymied by the French inheritance laws.

    Hence I spent my money of fine lodgings and good vacations.
    Like Adrian, it makes no sense. Within the city of Paris, and in other cities of the world, many of these apartments are too small for families. Fine for a professional couple.
    I don’t want it be holed up in a hotel room.
    Another point, I don’t think I’m the only person who waited for their vacation in Paris to do their personal shopping.
    I miss it so much. I’m almost to old to travel the exhausting journey from Australia.
    I just want one last bang up vacation in a home away from home.
    You know, the loss of the Leeds rental business, has been one of the greatest dissapointments of my life.

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 5, 2022 at 6:18 am

      Thanks so much and thanks for sharing your comments.

  10. Paul Davenport on August 4, 2022 at 8:35 pm

    My wife and I are retired and live in a small mountain town in southwest Colorado. STR’s weren’t really a thing when we moved here. We have a good bit of tourism which several hotels used to handle. Fast forward to the STR boom and what used to be neighborhoods with real neighbors are now filled with STR’s. Most have never had the owner stay at them but are simply a business venture, many owners having multiple STR’s. Our complaint is the loss of livability for full time residents, as we no longer have neighbors with whom to socialize and complain about things like STR’s. Our hotels, saddled with commercial tax rates and transient fees, can’t compete and are closing. A citizen ballot initiative recently passed requiring the town to charge a monthly per bedroom fee to all STR’s as full time residents were fed up with town and county government failing to take any action to control the loss of neighborhoods. The initiative is poorly written and government folks could have done much better controlling the issue themselves. While we are not anti-STR, we occasionally use them, we absolutely see the need to regulate them. I cannot speak to France’s solution as I don’t have enough information, but I can understand how government feels the need to step in, and likely gets significant pressure from a majority of residents to do so. Just another perspective.

    • Adrian Leeds Group on August 5, 2022 at 6:14 am

      Thanks for sharing your comments.

Leave a Comment




Let Adrian create a custom strategy for you

You can live or invest in France-now.

Property for sale

what's happening

Check out upcoming events, conferences, or webinars. Join us!

GET FINANCING

Learn about French Property Loan Information.

French Property Loan logo

Read & Subscribe

Dive into more by reading the Adrian Leeds Nouvellettre®

Better yet, subscribe to both and get the updates delivered to your inbox.

Adrian Leeds in red beret and sunglasses

Get started with your dream of owning property in Paris.

Advertise with Us

Deliver your message to 15,000+ Francophile readers in our Nouvellettres®

Save money on currency exchange. See who we use and recommend.